There are few things more frustrating than paying for a repair only to have the lights flicker, the breaker trip, or the plug point fail again a few days later. It is stressful, inconvenient, and frankly, annoying. You might worry that you have wasted money or, worse, that your home is unsafe.

If you find yourself in this situation, take a deep breath. Recurring electrical faults are surprisingly common, even with skilled electricians, because electrical systems in South African homes can be complex beasts. From ageing infrastructure in established suburbs to the stress load shedding puts on our distribution boards (DBs), sometimes a repair reveals a deeper layer of the problem.

Here is a step-by-step guide on how to handle the situation professionally, safely, and effectively to get it sorted out for good.

Step 1: Assess the Immediate Safety

Before you grab the phone, you need to ensure your home is safe. Electrical faults can be fire hazards.

• Smell: Is there a fishy or burning plastic smell? This usually indicates overheated insulation.
• Sound: Do you hear buzzing or crackling (arcing) from the switch or DB board?
• Heat: Is the wall or the switch plate hot to the touch?

If the answer is yes to any of these: Switch off the main supply at your Distribution Board immediately. Do not wait. This is an emergency situation.

If the problem is just a nuisance (like a light not working or a breaker tripping occasionally) and there are no danger signs, you can proceed to the next steps calmly.

Step 2: Verify it is the Same Issue

Sometimes, what looks like the "same" problem is actually a new symptom of a different cause. Our vetted electricians often explain that electrical faults can be like peeling an onion.

For example, Johan, a master electrician in Pretoria, recently shared a story about a client whose earth leakage kept tripping. Johan replaced the faulty unit, and it worked perfectly for a week. When it tripped again, the client was understandably upset. However, upon a second inspection, Johan found that a rodent had chewed through a wire in the ceiling after the initial repair, likely disturbed by the work. It wasn't bad workmanship; it was bad luck and a new variable.

Check these basics before calling:

• Is it a specific appliance? If your power trips only when you turn on the kettle, the fault might be the kettle, not the wiring the electrician fixed.
• Is it Load Shedding related? Sometimes, the surge when power returns can trip sensitive breakers. This is not necessarily a repair failure but a grid issue.
• Is it a globes issue? If a light isn't working, test the bulb in another fitting to rule out a blown globe.

Step 3: Check Your Paperwork and Warranty

In South Africa, you have rights protecting you against poor workmanship.

• The Consumer Protection Act (CPA): Under the CPA, verified repairs generally carry an implied warranty of quality for up to six months. If the same part fails or the workmanship is at fault, the service provider usually has a legal obligation to fix it.
• Workmanship Guarantee: Reputable trade pros often offer their own specific workmanship guarantee. Check the invoice or quote you received.
• SANS 10142-1 Standards: All electrical work must comply with South African National Standards. If a contractor bypasses safety protocols, they are liable to rectify it.

Step 4: Contact the Electrician Calmly

This is the most critical step. Your approach determines how quickly and willingly the contractor will return. Most reputable electricians take pride in their work and want to know if a job didn't hold up. They view a callback as a chance to protect their reputation.

How to make the call:

1. Be specific: Don't just say "it's broken again." Say, "The earth leakage you replaced on Tuesday tripped again this morning at 08:00 when I switched on the pool pump."
2. Be polite but firm: Avoid accusations. Start with, "I’m sure it’s just a complication, but the issue has returned."
3. Request a site visit: Ask them to come back to inspect why the repair failed.

Pro Tip: If you received a Certificate of Compliance (CoC) for the work (which you should for major alterations), the electrician is legally bound by his signature on that document to ensure the installation is safe and compliant.

Common Reasons Electrical Fixes "Fail"

To help you understand what might be happening, here are insights from industry data on why faults recur:

• Intermittent Faults: These are the electrician's nightmare. A loose connection might make contact when it's cold but separate when it heats up. The electrician might test it while it's "working," causing them to miss the root cause.
• Surge Damage: In areas like Johannesburg and Cape Town, constant grid switching damages components over time. A "fixed" breaker might fail again quickly if another massive surge hits it the next day.
• Old Wiring: In older suburbs like Woodstock or Parkhurst, the insulation on wires inside the walls can be brittle. Fixing one point might disturb another weak point nearby.

When to Get a Second Opinion

If the original contractor returns, tries again, and the problem persists—or if they refuse to return—it is time for a second opinion.

You should look for a new contractor if:

• The original electrician stops answering your calls.
• They claim the new issue is "completely unrelated" without explaining why in a way that makes sense.
• They refuse to issue a CoC for major work.

Note on Costs: If a second electrician finds that the first one made a mistake, document everything. Take photos of the faulty work. You may be able to claim a refund from the original provider via the Small Claims Court or the Electrical Conformance Board (ECB), though this can be a lengthy process.

Prevention Checklist: Before the Electrician Leaves

To avoid the "callback loop" in the future, follow this checklist before the electrician drives away:

1. Test under load: Don't just flip the switch. Turn on multiple appliances (stove, geyser, kettle) to ensure the system holds up under stress.
2. Ask "What if?": Ask the electrician, "If this trips again, what should I check first?"
3. Get the receipt: Ensure you have an invoice detailing exactly what was done and what parts were replaced. This is your proof for any warranty claims.
4. Check the CoC: For any work on the distribution board or new circuits, ensure you discuss the Certificate of Compliance.

Final Thoughts

Recurring electrical problems are frustrating, but they are rarely unfixable. By understanding your rights under the CPA and approaching the electrician with clear, specific information, you can usually get the issue resolved without paying double. Remember that electrical systems are dangerous; never attempt to "tweak" a repair yourself to save time.

If you want to understand more about pricing so you know if you are being quoted fairly for a re-visit or new job, check out our detailed guide on electrician prices in South Africa.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to pay if the electrician has to come back? It depends on the cause. If the original workmanship or the part supplied was faulty, you should not pay (protected by the CPA). However, if the electrician discovers a new problem or if the recurrence was caused by something outside their control (such as a lightning strike or a load-shedding surge), a call-out fee and labour costs will apply.

How long is the warranty on electrical repairs in South Africa? Under the Consumer Protection Act, there is generally an implied 6-month warranty for parts and labour for repairs. Additionally, many reputable electricians offer their own 12-month guarantee on workmanship. Always ask for this in writing before work begins.

What if the electrician blames "load shedding" for the recurring fault? This is a valid possibility. The surge of electricity returning after load shedding can blow fuses and damage sensitive components immediately after they are replaced. We recommend installing surge protection devices on your DB board to rule this out and protect your appliances.

Can I fix a recurring tripping breaker myself? No. Aside from being illegal to tamper with your DB board without a wireman’s license, it is extremely dangerous. If a breaker keeps tripping, it is doing its job by protecting you from an overload or short circuit. Forcing it to stay on or replacing it yourself can lead to electrical fires.

What should I do if the electrician ghosts me after I complain? If a contractor ignores you after a failed repair, send a formal message summarising the issue and the date of the original payment. If they still do not respond, you can report them to the Electrical Conformance Board of South Africa (ECB) or the Department of Labour if the installation is non-compliant.

‍